The Perfect Music App ⇥ hicks.design

Jon Hicks, last year:

Music apps leave me wanting.

While I collect albums both physically (Vinyl + CD) and digitally (from Bandcamp), there are still missing pieces that streaming services provide: discovering new music, sharing playlists and seeing what friends are playing so that I can try their recommendations. They’re a valuable part of my listening habits, but none of them feel like ‘the one’. […]

I only stumbled across this today, but it remains a wonderful encapsulation of the state of music apps today. I share Hicks’ criteria, though I would add three things for myself:

  1. More expansive metadata. I would like genres that work more like tags. An artist may generally make records in one genre, but different albums have different influences. Even individual songs may considerably differ in sound and style. This is the kind of thing that would help me make playlists or find songs that sound better together.

    This would be a management challenge across the tens of thousands of songs in my library, but I feel like integration with RateYourMusic and other databases might help partially automate this.

  2. iPhone syncing over a wire. One of Hicks’ criteria is streaming and local library in the same app, and I completely agree. But I do not want anything — especially iPhone syncing — to be predicated on an assumption I have Apple’s first-party iCloud Music stuff turned on.

  3. No lock-in. I want to be able to point it at my existing library and for things to just work. I would like to be able to import my entire setup from Music — all my playlists, including smart playlists, plus all my stats and ratings — and I would like it to be stored in a format some other application could read if I ever need to move to a different client in the future.

There are many indie apps that get close to this. I checked out Radiccio recently, but it unfortunately does not work with the iMac on which my music library is stored. Maybe that is the fourth criteria: backwards compatibility as far as possible.

Nobody has ever said I am easy to please.